Posts Tagged ‘digital word-of-mouth’

When Wolves Knock At The Door, The Herd Thins.

Thursday, January 22nd, 2009


Circuit City going out of business

Originally uploaded by F33

In my recent blog post, 5 Marketing Questions To Ask In A Recession, I discussed how October 2008 changed everything. Business is now more competitive than ever. As a result, most every business out there will have to re-think their marketing. Most will also have to improve their products and services. Because recessions like the one we’re looking at right now have a cruel way of thinning the herd.

We’re now seeing brands suffer that we never dreamed would. Most notable, the 3 major automobile manufacturers, who are now relying on the US government to bail them out. Circuit City has declared bankruptcy and is closing all of its 567 stores. Even Microsoft announced today that they’ll be laying off 5,000 employees, the first massive layoff in the company’s 34-year history. These are just a few examples.

While marketing isn’t the only reason some of our largest brands have suffered, I do believe in many cases it has played a role. Obviously business strategy has played a major role, as well.

But now, the playing field has changed for just about everyone. And competition is heating up.

All of this reminds me of a game we played in my copywriting course in college. The game was called “Knock-Knock.”

The way the game worked was, we all had to line up outside the classroom door. Then one by one, we’d knock on the door. Our professor would crack the door open. At that point, each student would have to say why the professor should open the door. And the professor wouldn’t let us in until we  came up with a good reason.

I now understand and appreciate that game more than ever. It was a very simple yet effective demonstration of how marketing really works.

Right now, you’re probably having more trouble getting into some doors. Or perhaps you’re already on the inside, but you feel the pressure of trying to stay there because you know others are now knocking to get in and take your place.

Your relationships with your clients and customers may have kept you where you are for some time now. But when times get tough, relationships will get sacrificed for the bottom line. As the saying goes, “Nothing personal, it’s just business.”

As I’ve said before, October 2008 changed everything.

Are you developing the right kind of marketing strategies and brand messages that will push your business to the other side of this recession? Are you implementing social media strategies to create digital word-of-mouth for your brand? Are you giving your audience a reason to open the door that is better than the reason you had last year?

If not, you might want to get serious about your plan for 2009. Because you can bet that someday soon there will be wolves knocking on your clients’ doors.

–Kevin McIntosh

5 Marketing Questions To Ask In A Recession

Wednesday, January 21st, 2009


recession lane

Originally uploaded by ZenTraveler

October 2008 changed everything. It changed credit availability for businesses and consumers. It wiped out consumer confidence. And it must change the way businesses market.

Why? Because business is now more competitive than ever.

Since October, you’ve likely experienced at least one of the following:
1. Current clients/customers have cut back spending.
2. Current clients/customers have totally stopped spending.
3. Prospective clients/customers have put planned expenditures on hold.

Furthermore, your current clients/customers may be getting more attention from your competitors who are trying to make up for their lost business as well.

If you thought business was competitive before, you haven’t seen anything yet. Recessions are the business world’s way of thinning the herd.

It’s now survival of the fittest. It’s the businesses who innovate and offer the best perceived value to their clients that will thrive in a recession.

So to keep on your competitive toes, here are 5 marketing-related questions business owners need to ask:
1. Is our marketing message as relevant today as it was before October?
Your marketing message may have worked for years. But an economic shake-up can change things real fast. What’s important to people when making purchasing decisions can change. Your marketing message may have to change, too.

2. If not, what should our new marketing message be?
Maybe it’s a value message. Maybe it’s a message that says your business is solid and is here for the long haul. Or it could be a message that reflects how your business is changing with the times to reflect the new economic environment. Look at what’s going on in your industry right now and ask how your marketing message can be adjusted to better reflect the times.

3. What new opportunities does the recession present for our business?
Are there new markets that have opened up for you? Perhaps larger clients would be more attracted to working with you than before for cost-savings reasons. Perhaps the service your business offers will now be attractive to companies who are now outsourcing for the first time due to employee cutbacks. Remember, just because some of your regular opportunities have dried up, doesn’t mean new ones can’t be created.

4. What can we do to provide greater value to our clients?
In a recession, everything becomes more value-driven than ever. Take a good honest look at your service and/or product to see what you can do to offer greater value. And make sure you communicate it in your marketing.

5. Is it time to explore new ways of getting our marketing message out there?
Some of the ways you’ve marketed over the past years may not be as effective now. That trade show that you’ve always spent much of your annual marketing budget on may not have a big turnout this year, as companies cut back on travel expenses. Perhaps this year, to get the ROI you need on marketing, you’ll need to start to leverage social media and public relations to your advantage to create digital word-of-mouth.

October 2008 changed everything. As a result, you are going to feel the competition breathing down your neck in the next year like never before.

If you want to survive this recession, the way you market will have to change.

–Kevin McIntosh

Facebook Sacrifices BK Whopper App

Thursday, January 15th, 2009

In my previous post, Burger King Whopper Sacrifice Promotion Tests Friendships, I discussed the new Facebook social media app launched by BK in conjunction with their ad agency, Crispin Porter+Bogusky.

The application rewarded anyone who dumped 10 Facebook friends with a free coupon for a BK Whopper. With 233,906 friends getting dumped, Facebook has in turn dumped the app.

One of the creatives at Crispin Porter+Bogusky gave me a heads up early in the week that the plug could get pulled. And sure enough, it’s happened.

Facebook sacrifices BK Whopper Promotion

Facebook sacrifices BK Whopper Promotion

According to a post published yesterday on Tech Crunch, Facebook said the application facilitated activity that ran counter to user privacy by notifying people when a user removes a friend.

My Crispin Porter+Bogusky contact has told me there are groups being formed to bring the app back.

According to a post in the LA Times Technology blog, 2 groups including  one called “Petition to Re-Enable Whopper Sacrifice,” have been formed on Facebook to bring the app back.

So who knows, if enough digital word-of-mouth persuades Facebook, we may see the BK Whopper Sacrifice app back again. In the meantime, you might want to hold off on dumping any friends until you know there’s a Whopper in it for you.

–Kevin McIntosh

Burger King Whopper Sacrifice Promotion Tests Friendships

Saturday, January 10th, 2009

Creating digital word-of-mouth requires thinking outside of the box. And that’s just what Burger King’s ad agency, Crispin Porter Bogusky is doing with the new BK Whopper Sacrifice Facebook promotion.

The idea behind the promotion is that you can trade in 10 of your Facebook friends for a free Burger King Whopper.

BK Whopper Facebook Application Promotion

BK Whopper Facebook Application Promotion

What I like about the idea, is that it gets people talking. Even if someone is exposed to the idea but doesn’t act on trading in friends, they can still talk about it. And even better, is that the whole promotion is built around Facebook, which is all about conversations.

The application sends a message to each of the banished friends, bluntly alerting them that they were traded in for a free Whopper. Which is sure to generate additional conversations.

I’ve installed the app on my Facebook profile and it does create a nice visual on my profile page that reads, “Kevin is 10 sacrifices away from a free Whopper.” And asks, “Who will be next?”

One disappointment is that the installation does not appear to generate a Facebook story feed in my profile announcing, “Kevin has added the BK Whopper Sacrifice App to his profile.” With something extra like, “Be careful, or he could trade you in on a Whopper. If you’d like to trade Kevin in, click here.” Such a feed would generate a lot more digital word-of-mouth as it would begin to appear in status updates visible by my friends who are checking out my status updates.

This puzzles me since Facebook tends to generate a feed on about any other similar social action I choose. Perhaps I’ve missed something there.

I’d also be curious if the application announces a friend has been dumped on the friend’s feed as well. That would generate a lot more conversation, i.e. ribbing from their friends.

Measuring The Campaign’s Success
Since the application’s launch in late December, nearly 75,000 Facebookers have been traded in for a BK Whopper. That amounts to more than 7,000 coupons for free Whoppers.

But as is the case with social media, there are results that this campaign has created that we can’t measure. We can guess that 75,000 conversations probably at the minimum have occurred as a result of those who’ve received messages saying they’ve been dumped for a Whopper. But that number could 2x, 3x or more.

Another thing we can’t measure is how many people have purchased Whoppers sans coupon simply as a result of all the online and offline conversations and media publicity the promotion is generating. The story has been picked up a number of media outlets including the NY Times.

And I guess another thing we can’t measure is the negative impact it might have. If you were one of the friends to receive an email saying that you had been dumped for a BK Whopper, how would that influence your opinion of the brand? My hunch is that BK understand their audience well enough to realize that anyone that uptight has already been turned off by previous BK advertising anyway.

Despite the lack of measurability other than overall BK sales, I can’t imagine there’s not a marketer out there that wouldn’t love a marketing tactic that has this much potential to create digital word-of-mouth as well as traditional word-of-mouth.

From my own monitoring of the consumer feedback on blogs and such, the reactions are mixed. Which seems to be the case with anything online that generates response from more than a handful of people. Some love the cleverness of the idea, while others feel it’s crude and insulting.

Regardless, other conversations surrounding the promotion are starting to take place, even among those who haven’t traded-in friends. I’ve noted 2 of my Facebook friends have shared the BK Whopper sacrifice news stories on their profiles in the past 24 hours, as have I. Also, it’s generating some fun, as we’re now posting messages to each others’ profiles as the promotion ultimately leads to the burning question: “Which is worth more to you–my friendship or a BK Whopper?”

–Kevin McIntosh